Spell
QuickMistaken Accusation
View:
2590
If your opponent has more total cards in their hand and their side of the field than you do: Target 1 face-up card on the field; neither player can activate cards with that name, or their effects, for the rest of this Duel, except that target. You can only activate 1 "Mistaken Accusation" per turn.
Mistaken Accusation — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 62 ± 5 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 67 · Deck: 63 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Floodgate/Control · Secondary: Negation/Interaction
Why it scores here
Mistaken Accusation is a specialized going-second floodgate that locks a target card's name for the entire duel, preventing both players from activating it or using its effects. It appears in 53 decks across 14 archetypes, almost exclusively (90.6%) in going-second strategies paired with Harpie's Feather Duster and Crackdown, indicating strong matchup-specific value. However, its effectiveness is heavily dependent on the board state, requiring the opponent to have more cards than you to activate, and it provides no card advantage or combo generation. Without combo board evidence or guide analysis, the scoring reflects its practical role as a mid-game lock rather than a deck engine.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 70 | Quick-Play Spell naturally accessible in going-second matchups where the opponent typically has more cards; 53 decks across multiple archetypes confirm practical deployment. (verified) |
| Combo & Conversion | 50 | Non-combo card providing disruption rather than acceleration; effectiveness depends entirely on target selection and opponent's deck composition. (inferred) |
| Resource Economy | 35 | Pure −1 card cost with no advantage generation, refuel, or searching; value derives from disruption rather than economy. (verified) |
| Effect & Interaction | 80 | Permanent name-lock preventing both activation and effects is strong disruption; paired in 90%+ of decks with going-second staples like Crackdown and Solemn Judgment. (observed) |
| Material Utility | 5 | Spell Card cannot serve as Synchro/Xyz/Fusion material; no alternative material route evident. (verified) |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 70 | Once resolved, the lock persists for the entire duel without interruption; multi-turn value through permanent effect. (inferred) |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 65 | Low garnet potential and splashable as a 1-of tech across 14 distinct archetypes; no deck-building restrictions observed. (observed) |
Calculation
Weight profile: Primary role: Floodgate/Control. Intrinsic ≈ 67, Deck ≈ 63, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: Conditional activation penalty (-3). Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Permanent board lock on target card name for the rest of duel
- Splashable across multiple going-second strategies without deck-building cost
- Quick-Play allows activation during opponent's turn for reactive disruption
- Low garnet potential; viable as single-copy tech
Weaknesses
- Requires opponent to have more cards (conditional activation gate)
- No card advantage or refuel generation
- Ineffective in going-first or resource-even scenarios
- Effectiveness entirely dependent on correct target selection
Counters / choke points
- Decks that search key cards into hand instead of leaving them on field
- Cards with already-active effects that resolve before being locked
- Decks with significant redundancy where locking one piece doesn't cripple the strategy
Best use
Going-second floodgate/control tech. Decks: Red-Eyes (17% of sample), Archfiend (17%), Borrel (15.1%), Dragon Link (15.1%), Rokket (15.1%). Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: Quick-Play Spell; locks target card name for rest of duel; 53 decks actively run the card across recent formats; 90.6% of sample is going-second gameplay; Pure −1 card cost with no advantage generation or refuel; Spell Card cannot be used as Synchro/Xyz/Fusion material
- Observed: 90.6% of decks pair with Harpie's Feather Duster (going-second package); 88.7% paired with Crackdown, Solemn Judgment, Anti-Spell Fragrance (going-second staples); Predominantly run as 1-copy tech (48/53 decks), occasionally 3-copy (5/53); Zero combo board appearances across supplied combo database
- Inferred: Activation condition (opponent ahead) is naturally met in opening turns of going-second turns; Locking a key opponent card (e.g., Archfiend Eccentrick, Ancient Gear Fusion) provides strong strategic disruption; Once resolved, lock persists without any further upkeep or interruption points; Symmetric lock design reflects intended going-second use case where opponent is naturally resource-ahead
- Data gaps: No combos supplied (spell card, not combo-piece material) No guides supplied (limits context on practical adoption/reasoning) No StatisticsCard usage data (archetype inclusion % inferred from 53-deck sample only) No metagame ranking data or top-card context No banlist information (assumed unlimited at 3 legal copies per format)






